Ben Goldacre
Thursday June 19, 2003
The Guardian
· The plural of anecdote is not data. Although it’s always very tempting. So although I’ll contain my evil desires to titillate you with tales of patients who’ve needed liver transplants after taking Chinese herbal remedies, I’m very amused by an article in the Lancet about a Chinese remedy company who seem to be putting artificial drugs in their potions. Spes capsules were examined by physicians treating a patient who developed Cushing’s Syndrome and were found to contain betamethasone, a potent synthetic glucocorticoid you wouldn’t expect to find in any magic herb. They also found alprazolam, a synthetic benzodiazepine much like the addictive “mother’s little helpers” of the 60s, which might go some way to explain the improvement in “quality of life” claimed for Spes. Neither was mentioned on the label. Alternative therapy fans might bear in mind that, if a herbal remedy works it’s probably got something potent in it.
· A BMJ paper recently found that children being treated with Chinese herbal skin creams for eczema were on average receiving five times the recommended adult dose of dexamethasone, a potent steroid. Which makes it very amusing that the alternative medicine lobby has ganged up against an EU directive to use proper ingredients labels and submit to regulation, like anyone else peddling a medicine. They say it’s part of a campaign by the medical establishment to discredit their products, and 5,000 people marched against the regulations in London last Sunday. They had Tory MP John Redwood lambasting the EU for over-regulating us. But even the Daily Mail, champion of anecdotal evidence, favourably reported a study of 200,000 people that showed a 0.4% increase in deaths from all causes in people taking beta-carotene supplements, and no benefit at all from vitamin E.
· 200,000 people seems to be enough for a study disproving alternative therapies to be taken seriously. If you’re in the business of promoting pseudoscience, standards seem to be less stringent. Last weekend’s Sunday Telegraph devoted the whole of page 3 to alternative therapy porn, with a story on how drinking the Queen’s Royal Deeside spring water improved arthritis symptoms in two-thirds of patients. It was a study of 34 patients over three months and there was no control group. It’s hard to imagine an experiment where it would have been easier to come up with a convincing placebo. Water.
Ben Goldacre said,
September 17, 2005 at 3:25 pm
Can somone remind me I should follow up on this and see if they’ve actually published the research like they said they were going to?
Dr* T said,
August 13, 2007 at 1:16 pm
Hey Ben, Why don’t you follow up on this and see if they’ve actually published the research like they said they were going to.
Quixotematic said,
August 13, 2007 at 7:18 pm
Ben, with regard to Chinese herbal medicine, it is important that you be aware of the difference between ‘herbal medicine’ as actually practised in China and Traditional Chinese Medicine as marketed in the UK.
In China, little or no distinction is made between pharmaceuticals and phytopharmaceuticals. They have a habit of mix’n'matching the two, both in patent medicines and hospital pharmacies.
For this reason, imported patent medicines are watched hawkishly, not merely by agents of the state but also by members of bodies like the RCHM, who do not wish to see the waters of a lucrative pond muddied. Essentially its a problem with mainland Chinese exporters, not TCM practitioners in the UK.
No European-trained (and scrupulous) practitioner would ever sell a client any product ‘adulterated’ with nasty chemical drugs anyway, on the basis that it would injure the Qi of the herbs. Or similar.
So in short, ‘Imported Chinese Herbal Remedy Contains Pharmaceuticals’ shock, horror is not really a ‘man bites dog’ story. Just a dreary tale of poor import controls.
Munin said,
August 14, 2007 at 7:03 pm
Nice to see this story resurrected – unlike John Redwood, who’s also lobbying for herbal meds in one of the other Miniblog links.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2007/08/12/ntory112.xml
Perhaps it’s because he’s named after a red tree (rather than, say, a yellow field).
angmoh said,
August 15, 2007 at 11:46 am
“No European-trained (and scrupulous) practitioner would ever sell a client any product ‘adulterated’ with nasty chemical drugs anyway”.
No, ‘cos then it might actually work…
wokao123 said,
October 15, 2009 at 10:01 am
i like this article Links of London Links of London Links of London Links of London Tiffany Tiffany Tiffany Tiffany ED hardy ED hardy ED hardy UGG BOOTS UGG BOOTS UGG BOOTS UGG BOOTS
wayscj said,
November 21, 2009 at 6:52 am
ed hardy ed hardy
ed hardy clothing ed hardy clothing
ed hardy shop ed hardy shop
christian audigier christian audigier
ed hardy cheap ed hardy cheap
ed hardy outlet ed hardy outlet
ed hardy sale ed hardy sale
ed hardy store ed hardy store
ed hardy mens ed hardy mens
ed hardy womens ed hardy womens
ed hardy kids ed hardy kids ed hardy kids