Kelliher’s been busy with email@example.com
It’s a definite improvement on the really rather revolting blog postings from the Portwood camp but addresses none of the interesting questions, and simply re-states the blander aspects of the case which have already been torpedoed. There are now much more interesting things to say on this than go over old ground, but one thing that amuses me is: if their “initiative” hadn’t been presented as important scientific research, four weeks ago, but instead had been presented merely as a company giving a nice freebie to a council, how many peak time national terrestrial TV news flagships do you think would have put the fish oil tablet story in their running orders?
Durham council’s fish-oil initiative
Tuesday October 3, 2006
Readers of Ben Goldacre (Bad science, September, 9, 16 and 23) might come away with the idea that my company’s collaboration with Durham county council to supply free eye q capsules to all GSCE students for the 2007 academic year is a publicity gimmick aimed at generating bogus research data. Nothing could be further from the truth. Dr Goldacre’s criticism seems aimed at what the initiative is not, rather than what it is. It not is a clinical trial, just an initiative aimed at giving a simple nutritional input – omega-3 and omega-6 oils – to GCSE students in a region where children are underperfoming. It has the enthusiastic support of the schools, the pupils and their parents.
There is a lot of research, some of it using eye q, and a significant part of it undertaken in Durham, indicating that ensuring a good input of fatty acids in the diet can have real benefits for brain function. In the classroom, this can mean enhanced concentration, and ability to absorb information. So the initiative is purely to see if supplementation may enhance academic performance. If children taking part show better than expected results next summer, this may pave the way for a full clinical trial to find out exactly why. Every major nutritional authority around the world calls for us to have more omega-3 in our diets.
Equazen has collaborated with Durham council in various projects in the past. I am constantly impressed with the way that a local authority in northern England is, on it’s own initiative, investigating the linkage between nutrition and classroom performance. This idea is now widely accepted, thanks to many others, including Jamie Oliver. There is, however, a lot of further work to be done. So I have no doubt that in coming years, giving omega-3 supplements to school children will be standard practice. Much of the reason for this understanding will be the pioneering and progressive work undertaken by the Durham county council.
ps to refresh your memory, check out how thoroughly Durham, Equazen, and Portwood all didn’t call it a trial here in the extra quotes:
It amazes me how we criticised Durham and Equazen for collecting data in such a stupid design of “trial”, but these people have all got completely preoccupied with the use of the word, “trial”, as if that was the point, whilst still cheerfully talking about collecting data from the exercise…